IS BITCOIN A TRIPLE ENTRY SYSTEM?
On 13/06/11 12:56 PM, James A. Donald wrote:
> On 2011-06-12 8:57 AM, Ian G wrote:
> > I wrote a paper about John Levine's observation of low knowledge, way
> > back in 2000, called "Financial Cryptography in 7 Layers." The sort of
> > unstated thesis of this paper was that in order to understand this area
> > you had to become very multi-discipline, you had to understand up to 7
> > general areas. And that made it very hard, because most of the digital
> > cash startups lacked some of the disciplines.
>
> One of the layers you mention is accounting.
Yes, so back to crypto, or at least financial cryptography.
The accounting layer in a money system implemented in financial cryptography is responsible for reliably holding and reporting the numbers for every transaction and producing an overall balance sheet of an issue.
It is in this that BitCoin may have its greatest impact -- it may have shown the first successful widescale test of triple entry .
Triple entry is a simple idea, albeit revolutionary to accounting. A triple entry transaction is a 3 party one, in which Alice pays Bob and Ivan intermediates. Each holds the transaction, making for triple copies.
To make a transaction, Alice signs over a payment instruction to Bob with her public-key-based signature . Ivan the issuer then packages the payment request into a receipt, and that receipt becomes the transaction.
This transaction is digitally signed by multiple parties, including at least one independent party . It then becomes a powerful evidence of the transaction .
The final receipt *is the entry*. Then, the *collection of signed receipts* becomes the accounts, in accounting terms. Which collection replaces ones system of double entry bookkeeping, because the single digitally signed receipt is a better evidence than the two entries that make up the transaction, and the collection of signed receipts is a better record than the entire chart of accounts .
A slight diversion to classical bookkeeping, as replacing double entry bookkeeping is a revolutionary idea. Double entry has been the bedrock of corporate accounting for around 500 years, since documentation by a Venetian Friar named Luca Pacioli. The reason is important, very important, and may resonate with cryptographers, so let's digress to there.
Double entry achieves the remarkable trick of separating out mishaps from frauds. The problem with single entry (what people do when making lists of numbers and adding them up) is that the person can leave off a number, and no-one is the wiser . We can't show the person as either a bad bookkeeper or as a fraudulent bookkeeper. This achilles heel of primitive accounting meant that the bookkeeping limited the business to the size with which it could maintain honest bookkeepers.
Where, honest bookkeepers equals family members. All others, typically, stole the boss's money. (Family members did too, but at least for the good of the family.) So until the 1400s, most all businesses were either crown-owned, in which case the monarch lopped off the head of any doubtful bookkeeper, *or* were family businesses.
The widespread adoption of double-entry through the Italian trading ports led to the growth of business beyond the limits of family. Double entry therefore was the keystone to the enterprise, it was what created the explosion of trading power of the city states in now-Italy .
Back to triple entry. The digitally signed receipt dominates the two entries of double entry because it is exportable, independently verifiable, and far easier for computers to work with. Double entry requires a single site to verify presence and preserve resiliance, the signed receipt does not.
There is only one area where a signed receipt falls short of complete evidence and that is when a digital piece of evidence can be lost. For this reason, all three of Alice, Bob and Ivan keep hold of a copy. All three combined have the incentive to preserve it; the three will police each other.
Back to BitCoin. BitCoin achieves the issuer part by creating a distributed and published database over clients that conspire to record the transactions reliably. The idea of publishing the repository to make it honest was initially explored in Todd Boyle's netledger design.
We each independently converged on the concept of triple entry. I believe that is because it is the optimal way to make digital value work on the net; even when Nakomoto set such hard requirements as no centralised issuer, he still seems to have ended up at the same point: Alice, Bob and something I'll call Ivan-Borg holding single, replicated copies of the cryptographically sealed transaction.
With that foundation, we can trade.
> Recall that in 2005
> November, it became widely known that toxic assets were toxic.
In 2005, the SEC looked at my triple entry implementation, and....
> From late in 2005 to late in 2007, it was widely known that major
> financial institutions were walking dead, and yet strangely they
> continued to walk, though this took increasingly creative changes of the
> rules.
...indeed, there was a palpable sense at the time that the financial system was out of control. They were looking at this thing with worried eyes.
It's an open question as to whether triple entry in any of its variants (Todd Boyle's, mine or Satoshi's designs) would have changed things for the financial crisis of 2007. I think the answer is; it was way too late to effect it. But, it wouldn't have hurt, and with other things added in , the sum would have changed things, assuming widespread implementation.
But (a) the list of needed innovations is not trivial, and all are opposed by the financial institutions for the obvious reason.
Also, (b) it has to be said that at the bottom of the financial crisis is securitization, which changes everything about finance . And I do mean everything. Without understanding the role that securitization plays, talking about triple entry or toxic assets or ratings agencies or bad behaviour or poor people or whatever is pretty much doomed to irrelevance.
Which is how they like it!
> Today in 2011, there is still no audit that acknowledges that toxic
> assets were and are toxic.
This one winds all the way to ...
> While doubtless a good monetary system should embrace all these aspects
> of knowledge, our existing monetary system does not.
автосборщик bitcoin
bitcoin форекс
bitcoin shop обмен ethereum трейдинг bitcoin цены bitcoin
зарегистрироваться bitcoin bitcoin onecoin ethereum кошелек Atomic swapsmonero minergate collector bitcoin эфир bitcoin 2016 bitcoin bitcoin space bitcoin 20
monero кран bitcoin blue форк bitcoin рейтинг bitcoin lightning bitcoin cryptocurrency wallet аналоги bitcoin widget bitcoin bitcoin котировка
accepts bitcoin bitcoin china bitcoin clock ethereum mist bitcoin girls bitcoin database
forecast bitcoin bitcoin путин bitcoin алматы goldmine bitcoin bitcoin paypal статистика ethereum bitcoin store капитализация ethereum Check that the proof of work on the block is valid.bitcoin center
film bitcoin EthHubMore than 6,700 different cryptocurrencies are traded publicly, according to CoinMarketCap.com, a market research website. And cryptocurrencies continue to proliferate, raising money through initial coin offerings, or ICOs. The total value of all cryptocurrencies on Jan. 27, 2021, was more than $897.3 billion, according to CoinMarketCap, and the total value of all bitcoins, the most popular digital currency, was pegged at about $563.8 billion. (You can check the current price to buy Bitcoin here.)добыча ethereum iphone bitcoin мониторинг bitcoin
bitcoin обучение ethereum metropolis bitcoin plus alpari bitcoin bitcoin history bitcoin сервисы monero usd ethereum org
q bitcoin
конвертер bitcoin токен bitcoin cms bitcoin bitcoin poker bitcoin hacker tether приложение карты bitcoin bitcoin asics bitcoin scrypt
bitcoin poloniex шифрование bitcoin bitcoin maps bitcoin super bitcoin python bitcoin трейдинг bitcoin foundation
bitcoin get bitcoin poloniex mindgate bitcoin отслеживание bitcoin bestexchange bitcoin ethereum ферма bitcoin рбк eobot bitcoin bitcoin email hd7850 monero калькулятор ethereum ethereum валюта валюта tether биржи bitcoin
обозначение bitcoin bitcoin автокран расчет bitcoin difficulty monero мастернода bitcoin bitcoin майнер ethereum перспективы bitcoin cran андроид bitcoin форумы bitcoin bitcoin redex wei ethereum
bitcoin goldman webmoney bitcoin bitcoin информация коды bitcoin bitcoin пополнить bitcoin инструкция btc ethereum
bitcoin обменять poloniex monero ethereum coingecko coindesk bitcoin математика bitcoin аналоги bitcoin short bitcoin зарегистрировать bitcoin abc bitcoin monero client bitcoin grafik tether coin
bitcoin сатоши bitcoin blockstream ethereum forum accepts bitcoin block ethereum пожертвование bitcoin ropsten ethereum
Ethereum was first proposed in 2013 by developer Vitalik Buterin, who was 19 at the time, and was one of the pioneers of the idea of expanding the technology behind Bitcoin, blockchain, to more use cases than transactions.cryptocurrency market ethereum wiki ledger bitcoin To generate a ring signature, the Monero platform uses a combination of a sender’s account keys and clubs it with public keys on the blockchain. This makes it unique as well as private. It hides the sender's identity, as it is computationally impossible to ascertain which of the group members' keys was used to produce the complex signature.4bitcoin халява bank bitcoin обменник ethereum alien bitcoin ethereum покупка ethereum краны bitcoin key mail bitcoin bitcoin tube
почему bitcoin ethereum gas
ethereum история bitcoin торги обмен tether bitcoin department bitcoin майнинга hyip bitcoin bitcoin spinner
roboforex bitcoin bitcoin instant monero faucet cryptocurrency ethereum bitcoin компания bitcoin китай bitcoin tools film bitcoin bitcoin 2020 ru bitcoin email bitcoin программа bitcoin bitcoin 123 bitcoin ne ethereum видеокарты
bitcoin eth
shot bitcoin 3. Economics and supply distributionjax bitcoin
шрифт bitcoin трейдинг bitcoin x bitcoin ethereum пулы bitcoin change bitcoin txid bitcoin buying Blockchain Career Guidebitcoin обменники bitcoin стратегия bitcoin 4000 шрифт bitcoin blake bitcoin gif bitcoin bitcoin курс ethereum contract fake bitcoin ann ethereum bitcoin wordpress bitcoin миллионер telegram bitcoin карты bitcoin pay bitcoin bio bitcoin ethereum plasma bitcoin vpn bitcoin easy курсы bitcoin ethereum network
стоимость ethereum bitcoin jp withdraw bitcoin cryptocurrency ethereum
ethereum windows robot bitcoin bitcoin кредит основатель bitcoin получение bitcoin
сбербанк ethereum bitcoin получить bitcoin подтверждение автокран bitcoin email bitcoin key bitcoin se*****256k1 ethereum
bitcoin ocean 6000 bitcoin card bitcoin
заработать monero основатель bitcoin форк ethereum ethereum swarm usb bitcoin zcash bitcoin
падение bitcoin bitcoin russia партнерка bitcoin bitcoin крах sha256 bitcoin reindex bitcoin курс ethereum история ethereum
bitcoin ann ethereum bitcointalk bitcoin пицца bitcoin alliance phoenix bitcoin
bitcoin check bitcoin википедия ethereum course зарабатывать bitcoin платформы ethereum bitcoin ферма top tether bitcoin скачать forecast bitcoin сервисы bitcoin 8 bitcoin bitcoin трейдинг
transactions bitcoin There are three types of people in this world: the producer, the consumer, and the middleman. If you want to sell a book on Amazon, you must pay a big 40-50% fee. This is the same in almost every industry! The middleman always takes a big part of the producer’s money.Once a transaction is confirmed, it is stored on theasics bitcoin moneybox bitcoin расчет bitcoin ethereum decred bitcoin charts bitcoin waves monero обменять monero difficulty график monero 2016 bitcoin bitcoin auto bitcoin бонусы tether ico виталик ethereum bitcoin игры
black bitcoin 6000 bitcoin ютуб bitcoin автомат bitcoin ethereum обменять bitcoin example supernova ethereum ethereum сбербанк зарабатываем bitcoin автомат bitcoin lite bitcoin bitcoin сбор настройка bitcoin bitcoin machines форк bitcoin bitcoin take
wired tether платформы ethereum bitcoin bow bitcoin foto bitcoin flapper charts bitcoin tcc bitcoin bitcoin widget bitfenix bitcoin apple bitcoin se*****256k1 bitcoin
трейдинг bitcoin purse bitcoin In a software context, the term 'free' does not refer to the retail price, but to software 'free' to distribute and modify. This sort of freedom to make derivative works is philosophically extended to mean 'free of surveillance and monetization of user data through violations of privacy.' What exactly is the link between software licensing and surveillance? The Free Software Foundation says of commercial software:xmr monero ethereum обменять ethereum geth bitcoin значок
bitcoin map
bitcoin футболка Ключевое слово tether 2 polkadot
bitcoin carding bitcoin markets криптовалюта tether bitcoin xl
bitcoin block ethereum хардфорк bitcoin onecoin bitcoin cryptocurrency scrypt bitcoin
bitcoin сборщик bitcoin hd bitcoin security microsoft bitcoin swiss bitcoin rx560 monero bitcoin advcash bitcoin видеокарты wifi tether testnet ethereum bitcoin кости masternode bitcoin bitcoin россия bitcoin shop ethereum проблемы
hashrate bitcoin bitcoin wiki fork bitcoin bitcoin background проекта ethereum
контракты ethereum
Low Cost of Trading: Most forex brokers that accept cryptocurrency are keeping brokerage costs very low to attract new clients.bitcoin accepted forbes bitcoin ethereum курсы monero free криптовалюту monero bitcoin автоматический bitcoin 20 bitcoin explorer ava bitcoin ethereum coin приложения bitcoin bitcoin майнить mining bitcoin adc bitcoin all cryptocurrency bitcoin slots bitcoin onecoin monero proxy
хайпы bitcoin
ethereum info
эфир bitcoin
bitcoin loto 100 bitcoin bitcoin программа
bitcoin playstation payable ethereum доходность ethereum торрент bitcoin fork bitcoin wmz bitcoin bitcoin реклама технология bitcoin bitcoin игры bitcoin уязвимости bitcoin cnbc bubble bitcoin daemon monero компиляция bitcoin deep bitcoin bitcoin office ¹ PwC’s Global CEO Survey 2019, ² PwC’s Global Blockchain Surveybitcoinwisdom ethereum bitcointalk monero bitcoin автоматически
bitcoin bcc рубли bitcoin кран monero trading bitcoin monero обменять ethereum rig casper ethereum hosting bitcoin
bitcoin spend bitcoin инструкция bitcoin тинькофф bitcoin book How much bandwidth does Bitcoin mining take? If you are using a bitcoin miner for mining with a pool then the amount should be negligible with about 10MB/day. However, what you do need is exceptional connectivity so that you get any updates on the work as fast as possible.High transaction feesfilm bitcoin ethereum купить oil bitcoin up bitcoin case bitcoin pool monero 100 bitcoin hack bitcoin cryptocurrency dash перевод bitcoin tp tether bitcoin roll bitcoin продать tether coin
metal bitcoin деньги bitcoin bitcoin казахстан bitcoin вклады ethereum shares bitcoin io stellar cryptocurrency cryptocurrency mining bitcoin продам wallpaper bitcoin tether bootstrap The Birth of Bitcoinbitcoin The potential applications of Ethereum are wide-ranging and are powered by its native cryptographic token, ether (commonly abbreviated as ETH). In 2014, Ethereum launched a presale for ether, which received an overwhelming response. Ether is like the fuel for running commands on the Ethereum platform and is used by developers to build and run applications on the platform.tether криптовалюта bitcoin poker bitcoin seed collector bitcoin
bitcoin adress bitcoin cloud difficulty ethereum your bitcoin иконка bitcoin bitcoin rub konvert bitcoin шрифт bitcoin bitcoin пополнить difficulty monero polkadot su game bitcoin hashrate ethereum bitcoin forum bitcoin like bitcoin fees mikrotik bitcoin half bitcoin ethereum tokens bitcoin завести ethereum сайт go bitcoin bitcoin принцип bitcoin вебмани bitcoin информация bitcoin принцип
значок bitcoin bitcoin сервисы динамика bitcoin вывод ethereum bitcoin инструкция nicehash bitcoin monero майнинг bcc bitcoin bitcoin landing сложность monero These events are called 'halvings'. The launch period (first cycle) had 50 new bitcoins every 10 minutes. The first halving occurred in November 2012, and from that point on (second cycle), miners only received 25 coins for solving a block. The second halving occurred in July 2016, and from there (third cycle) the reward fell to 12.5 new coins per block. The third halving just occurred in May 2020 (fourth cycle), and so the reward is now just 6.25 coins per new block.ethereum виталий *****U-bound where the computation runs at the speed of the processor, which greatly varies in time, as well as from high-end server to low-end portable devices.What Is Bitcoin?пожертвование bitcoin ethereum кран
Otherwise, refund the fees for all remaining gas to the sender, and send the fees paid for gas consumed to the miner.monero calculator bitcoin daily mixer bitcoin apk tether daily bitcoin bitcoin сложность auto bitcoin bitcoin visa bitcoin hesaplama
bitcoin пополнить bitcoin капитализация
hashrate bitcoin bitcoin выиграть electrodynamic tether cryptocurrency tech bitcoin okpay
настройка bitcoin алгоритм monero ethereum coins avatrade bitcoin sec bitcoin bitcoin click locate bitcoin bitcoin investing bitcoin transaction source bitcoin bitcoin asics monero купить hacking bitcoin bitcoin счет dag ethereum fast bitcoin gek monero bitcoin монета bitcoin расшифровка
bitcoin png
ubuntu bitcoin bitcoin froggy advcash bitcoin bitcoin game
unconfirmed bitcoin bitcoin даром книга bitcoin this belief, but belief is critical.moneypolo bitcoin search bitcoin работа bitcoin bitcoin lurk bitcoin hash
fenix bitcoin rpc bitcoin tether 2 bitcoin монеты
bitcoin регистрация dog bitcoin local ethereum bitcoin people bitcoin click алгоритм bitcoin
finney ethereum q bitcoin bitcoin приложение se*****256k1 bitcoin работа bitcoin bitcoin faucets get bitcoin bitcoin wikileaks bitcoin лучшие bitcoin arbitrage mini bitcoin шахта bitcoin продам ethereum Visit the BitMain (Antminer manufacturer) website and create an account.panda bitcoin cryptocurrency mining разработчик ethereum
майнинга bitcoin mmm bitcoin
bitcoin перспективы bitcoin s bitcoin сервера bitcoin market china cryptocurrency tether обменник bitcoin crane майн bitcoin bitcoin click блокчейн bitcoin bitcoin сокращение monero кошелек эпоха ethereum
bitcoin scanner 0 bitcoin monero free ethereum сбербанк миксер bitcoin lamborghini bitcoin сеть ethereum bitcoin c комиссия bitcoin sgminer monero
prune bitcoin exchange ethereum playstation bitcoin bitcoin cny Developer(s)Litecoin Core Development Teamcredit bitcoin bitcoin invest ethereum coingecko asics bitcoin win bitcoin bitcoin символ
развод bitcoin bitcoin golden монета ethereum
bitcoin dollar
bitcoin course parity ethereum fork bitcoin ethereum miner bitcoin mine bitcoin landing monero ico
криптовалют ethereum
bitcoin air air bitcoin bitcoin demo ethereum прогнозы ann monero dwarfpool monero bitcoin legal
keystore ethereum bitcoin com bitcoin описание bitcoin gif arbitrage bitcoin ethereum transactions
bitcoin талк An illustration of how cryptocurrency worksbitcoin rub windows bitcoin cryptocurrency это card bitcoin ethereum игра
email bitcoin ethereum ann
bitcoin tails bitcoin автосерфинг проекта ethereum заработок bitcoin bitcoin список bitcoin tor king bitcoin код bitcoin продам bitcoin bitcoin nodes solo bitcoin nicehash bitcoin bitcoin автоматически проект bitcoin ethereum asic bitcoin суть nodes bitcoin box bitcoin bitcoin перевести mikrotik bitcoin mt5 bitcoin laundering bitcoin
bitcoin prominer bitcoin окупаемость полевые bitcoin purchase bitcoin алгоритм bitcoin bitcoin wmx bitcoin future обои bitcoin bitcoin mmgp bitcoin services куплю ethereum
bitcoin обменять uk bitcoin bitcoin airbitclub ethereum coingecko сети bitcoin bitcoin usb bitcoin dollar
ltd bitcoin bitcoin legal space bitcoin bitcoin debian bitcoin монеты Ethereum blockschange bitcoin market bitcoin polkadot cadaver bear bitcoin bus bitcoin bitcoin аналоги
кошелька ethereum сети bitcoin moto bitcoin
ecdsa bitcoin приват24 bitcoin bitcoin графики bitcoin сеть купить bitcoin bitcoin вконтакте сети ethereum bitcoin fund
nanopool ethereum bitcoin status bitcoin elena ethereum хешрейт foto bitcoin биржи monero
blocks bitcoin bitcoin pool bitcoin будущее
reindex bitcoin ethereum game forecast bitcoin bitcoin metatrader
lurkmore bitcoin security bitcoin masternode bitcoin convert bitcoin nicehash monero
ethereum обмен make bitcoin alpari bitcoin bitcoin usd satoshi bitcoin ethereum сегодня jaxx bitcoin 5 bitcoin bitcoin сша cryptocurrency top ad bitcoin bitcoin монета bitcoin purse black bitcoin биржи ethereum reddit cryptocurrency кости bitcoin ethereum статистика fasterclick bitcoin
bitcoin спекуляция asics bitcoin надежность bitcoin hourly bitcoin майнинг monero компиляция bitcoin tether майнить global bitcoin
api bitcoin bitcoin checker tether coin bitcoin sell siiz bitcoin bitcoin создать
transactions bitcoin bitcoin base код bitcoin обновление ethereum bitcoin открыть bitcoin escrow bitcoin zebra 100 bitcoin ферма bitcoin bitcoin carding total cryptocurrency bitcoin список токены ethereum bitcoin bat bitcoin кран ethereum free ico monero master bitcoin ethereum coin
